apophis-fastify/docs/attic/extensions/AUTH-RATE-LIMIT-REVISED.md

# APOPHIS v1.0 — Authentication, Authorization & Rate Limiting Extension (REVISED)

> **Status: NOT IMPLEMENTED**
> This document describes a proposed extension that is not yet available in APOPHIS. The predicates, types, and infrastructure described here do not exist in the current codebase. Use `createAuthExtension` from `@apophis/fastify/extension/factories` for auth testing today.

## 1. Overview

This document specifies the extension of APOPHIS v1.0 to support production-critical concerns:

1. **Authentication Flows** — JWT, OAuth 2.1, session-based, and mTLS authentication
2. **Rate Limiting** — Contract-level rate limit validation and burst testing
3. **Authorization/Scope Claims** — Fine-grained permission modeling in contracts

**Critical Design Constraint**: Arbiter (the primary production user) uses **programmatic gate-based auth**, not JSON Schema annotations. Routes validate auth in `preHandler` hooks, not via `schema:` properties. This spec supports **both** annotation-based and programmatic contract definition.

---

## 2. Design Principles

- **Auth is a cross-cutting concern**, not a route category
- **Two contract definition modes**:
  - **Annotation mode**: `x-auth`, `x-scopes`, `x-rate-limit` in JSON Schema (for standard REST APIs)
  - **Programmatic mode**: Pass auth/rate-limit config directly to `contract()`/`stateful()` (for gate-based architectures like Arbiter)
- **Test isolation**: Each test run receives its own auth context. No shared tokens across tests.
- **Deterministic when seeded**: Auth flows are simulated, not delegated to external IdPs. Token/session generation must receive the test seed and clock.
- **No breaking changes**: All new features are opt-in. Existing v1.0 contracts work unchanged.

---

## 3. Auth State Model

Auth state is tracked per-test-run in an `AuthContext` object:

```typescript
// src/types.ts (additions)

export type AuthFlow = 'jwt' | 'oauth2' | 'session' | 'mtls' | 'none'

export interface AuthContext {
  readonly flow: AuthFlow
  readonly token: string | null           // Current access token (JWT or OAuth)
  readonly refreshToken: string | null    // OAuth refresh token
  readonly tokenExpiry: number | null     // Unix timestamp (ms)
  readonly sessionCookie: string | null   // Session ID for cookie flows
  readonly clientCert: string | null      // mTLS client certificate
  readonly scopes: string[]               // Granted scopes
  readonly claims: Record<string, unknown> // Decoded claims (JWT payload or OAuth token introspection)
}

export interface AuthConfig {
  readonly flow: AuthFlow
  readonly issuer?: string
  readonly audience?: string
  readonly clientId?: string
  readonly clientSecret?: string
  readonly tokenEndpoint?: string
  readonly authorizationEndpoint?: string
  readonly scopes?: string[]
  readonly testKeyPair?: { publicKey: string; privateKey: string }
  readonly sessionSecret?: string
  readonly clientCert?: string           // PEM-encoded client certificate for mTLS
  readonly clientKey?: string            // PEM-encoded client private key for mTLS
}
```

---

## 4. Contract Definition Modes

### 4.1 Annotation Mode (JSON Schema)

For APIs that use schema annotations, auth requirements are declared in the schema:

```typescript
fastify.get('/users/:id', {
  schema: {
    params: { type: 'object', properties: { id: { type: 'string' } } },
    response: {
      200: {
        type: 'object',
        properties: { id: { type: 'string' }, email: { type: 'string' } },
        'x-auth': 'jwt',
        'x-scopes': ['read:users'],
        'x-ensures': ['jwt_claims(this).sub != null']
      }
    }
  }
}, handler)
```

**Annotation semantics**:

- `x-auth`: Required auth flow. Values: `"jwt"`, `"oauth2"`, `"session"`, `"mtls"`, `"none"` (default).
- `x-scopes`: Array of scope strings. Checked against `AuthContext.scopes`.
- `x-scopes-match`: `"any"` (at least one) or `"all"` (all required). Default: `"any"`.
- `x-auth-optional`: If `true`, route works with or without auth.

### 4.2 Programmatic Mode (No Schema Annotations)

For architectures like Arbiter that don't use schema annotations for auth, pass auth requirements directly to the test runner:

```typescript
// Arbiter-style: auth is handled in preHandler gates, not schema annotations
const suite = await fastify.apophis.contract({
  scope: 'tenant-a',
  auth: {
    flow: 'jwt',
    issuer: 'https://auth.example.com',
    scopes: ['read:users', 'read:posts']
  },
  // Optional: per-route auth overrides
  routeAuth: {
    'GET /users/:id': { requiredScopes: ['read:users'] },
    'POST /admin/users': { requiredScopes: ['admin'], scopesMatch: 'all' }
  }
})
```

**Programmatic mode semantics**:

- `auth` in `TestConfig` initializes the auth context for the entire test run
- `routeAuth` provides per-route auth requirements when schemas don't have annotations
- Auth headers are injected into all requests automatically
- Postconditions can still use `jwt_claim(this).sub` etc. to validate claims in responses

---

## 5. Type Changes in `src/types.ts`

### 5.1 RouteContract Extension

```typescript
export interface RouteContract {
  path: string
  method: string
  category: OperationCategory
  requires: string[]
  ensures: string[]
  invariants: string[]
  regexPatterns: Record<string, string>
  validateRuntime: boolean
  schema?: Record<string, unknown>
  // NEW:
  authFlow: AuthFlow
  requiredScopes: string[]
  scopesMatch: 'any' | 'all'
  authOptional: boolean
  rateLimit?: RateLimitConfig
}
```

### 5.2 EvalContext Extension

```typescript
export interface EvalContext {
  readonly request: { /* ... */ }
  readonly response: { /* ... */ }
  readonly previous?: EvalContext
  // NEW:
  readonly auth: AuthContext
}
```

### 5.3 TestConfig Extension

```typescript
export interface TestConfig {
  readonly depth?: TestDepth
  readonly scope?: string
  readonly seed?: number
  // NEW:
  readonly auth?: AuthConfig
  readonly routeAuth?: Record<string, { requiredScopes?: string[]; scopesMatch?: 'any' | 'all'; authOptional?: boolean }>
  readonly burst?: boolean  // Enable burst testing for rate limits
}
```

### 5.4 ApophisOptions Extension

```typescript
export interface ApophisOptions {
  readonly swagger?: Record<string, unknown>
  readonly runtime?: 'off' | 'warn' | 'error'
  readonly cleanup?: boolean
  readonly scopes?: Record<string, ScopeConfig>
  // NEW:
  readonly auth?: AuthConfig
}
```

---

## 6. APOSTL Extensions for Auth

New operation headers for auth introspection:

```typescript
export type OperationHeader = 
  | 'request_body' | 'response_body' | 'response_code' 
  | 'request_headers' | 'response_headers' | 'query_params' 
  | 'cookies' | 'response_time'
  // NEW:
  | 'jwt_claim' | 'auth_scope' | 'rate_limit_remaining' | 'rate_limit_limit' | 'rate_limit_reset'
```

**New formula syntax**:

```
jwt_claims(this).sub == "user-123"
jwt_claims(this).role == "admin"
auth_has_scope(this, "read:users") == true
auth_has_scope(this, "admin") == true
rate_limit_remaining(this) >= 0
rate_limit_limit(this) == 100
```

**Semantics**:

- `jwt_claim(this).<claim>`: Access a claim from the decoded JWT payload. Returns `undefined` if no JWT or claim missing.
- `auth_scope(this).<scope>`: Returns `true` if the scope is present in `AuthContext.scopes`, `false` otherwise.
- `rate_limit_remaining(this)`: Returns the number of requests remaining in the current window (from response headers).
- `rate_limit_limit(this)`: Returns the total request limit for the window.
- `rate_limit_reset(this)`: Returns the Unix timestamp when the rate limit window resets.

---

## 7. Token Generation Helpers for Testing

New module: `src/infrastructure/auth-test-helpers.ts`

```typescript
/**
 * Auth Test Helpers
 * Deterministic token generation for testing. No external IdP calls.
 */

import { createSign, createVerify, randomBytes, createHash, createHmac } from 'node:crypto'

export interface TestKeyPair {
  readonly publicKey: string
  readonly privateKey: string
}

export const generateTestKeyPair = (): TestKeyPair => {
  const { privateKey, publicKey } = crypto.generateKeyPairSync('rsa', {
    modulusLength: 2048,
    publicKeyEncoding: { type: 'spki', format: 'pem' },
    privateKeyEncoding: { type: 'pkcs8', format: 'pem' },
  })
  return { publicKey, privateKey }
}

export const signTestJwt = (
  payload: Record<string, unknown>,
  privateKey: string,
  options: { expiresIn?: number; issuer?: string; audience?: string } = {}
): string => {
  const header = { alg: 'RS256', typ: 'JWT' }
  const now = Math.floor(Date.now() / 1000)
  const claims = {
    ...payload,
    iat: now,
    exp: options.expiresIn ? now + options.expiresIn : now + 3600,
    ...(options.issuer ? { iss: options.issuer } : {}),
    ...(options.audience ? { aud: options.audience } : {}),
  }
  
  const headerB64 = Buffer.from(JSON.stringify(header)).toString('base64url')
  const claimsB64 = Buffer.from(JSON.stringify(claims)).toString('base64url')
  const signingInput = `${headerB64}.${claimsB64}`
  
  const signer = createSign('RSA-SHA256')
  signer.update(signingInput)
  const signature = signer.sign(privateKey, 'base64url')
  
  return `${signingInput}.${signature}`
}

export const verifyTestJwt = (token: string, publicKey: string): Record<string, unknown> | null => {
  const [headerB64, claimsB64, signature] = token.split('.')
  if (!headerB64 || !claimsB64 || !signature) return null
  
  const verifier = createVerify('RSA-SHA256')
  verifier.update(`${headerB64}.${claimsB64}`)
  const valid = verifier.verify(publicKey, signature, 'base64url')
  
  if (!valid) return null
  return JSON.parse(Buffer.from(claimsB64, 'base64url').toString())
}

export const generateTestSessionCookie = (sessionId: string, secret: string): string => {
  const signature = createHmac('sha256', secret).update(sessionId).digest('base64url')
  return `session=${sessionId}.${signature}`
}

export const parseTestSessionCookie = (cookie: string, secret: string): string | null => {
  const match = cookie.match(/session=([^;]+)/)
  if (!match) return null
  const [sessionId, signature] = match[1].split('.')
  if (!sessionId || !signature) return null
  const expected = createHmac('sha256', secret).update(sessionId).digest('base64url')
  return signature === expected ? sessionId : null
}
```

---

## 8. OAuth 2.1 Grant Flow Simulation

New module: `src/infrastructure/oauth-simulator.ts`

```typescript
/**
 * OAuth 2.1 Grant Flow Simulator
 * Simulates authorization code, client credentials, and PKCE flows
 * without external IdP dependency. Returns tokens deterministically.
 */

import { signTestJwt, generateTestKeyPair } from './auth-test-helpers.js'
import type { AuthContext, AuthConfig } from '../types.js'
import { randomBytes, createHash } from 'node:crypto'

export interface OAuthSimulationResult {
  readonly accessToken: string
  readonly refreshToken: string
  readonly tokenType: 'Bearer'
  readonly expiresIn: number
  readonly scope: string
}

export class OAuthSimulator {
  private readonly keyPair: TestKeyPair
  private readonly config: AuthConfig
  private codeChallengeStore: Map<string, string> = new Map()

  constructor(config: AuthConfig) {
    this.config = config
    this.keyPair = config.testKeyPair ?? generateTestKeyPair()
  }

  async authorizationCode(params: {
    code: string
    codeVerifier?: string
    redirectUri: string
    clientId: string
  }): Promise<OAuthSimulationResult> {
    if (params.codeVerifier) {
      const challenge = this.codeChallengeStore.get(params.code)
      const verifierHash = createHash('sha256').update(params.codeVerifier).digest('base64url')
      if (verifierHash !== challenge) {
        throw new Error('invalid_grant: PKCE verification failed')
      }
    }
    return this.issueToken(params.clientId, this.config.scopes ?? ['openid'])
  }

  async clientCredentials(params: {
    clientId: string
    clientSecret: string
    scope?: string
  }): Promise<OAuthSimulationResult> {
    if (params.clientSecret !== `secret-${params.clientId}`) {
      throw new Error('invalid_client: Client authentication failed')
    }
    const scopes = params.scope ? params.scope.split(' ') : (this.config.scopes ?? [])
    return this.issueToken(params.clientId, scopes)
  }

  async authorize(params: {
    responseType: string
    clientId: string
    redirectUri: string
    scope?: string
    state?: string
    codeChallenge?: string
    codeChallengeMethod?: 'S256' | 'plain'
  }): Promise<{ code: string; state?: string }> {
    if (params.responseType !== 'code') {
      throw new Error('unsupported_response_type')
    }
    const code = randomBytes(16).toString('hex')
    if (params.codeChallenge) {
      this.codeChallengeStore.set(code, params.codeChallenge)
    }
    return { code, state: params.state }
  }

  private issueToken(clientId: string, scopes: string[]): OAuthSimulationResult {
    const accessToken = signTestJwt(
      { sub: clientId, scope: scopes.join(' '), client_id: clientId },
      this.keyPair.privateKey,
      { issuer: this.config.issuer, audience: this.config.audience, expiresIn: 3600 }
    )
    const refreshToken = randomBytes(32).toString('base64url')
    return {
      accessToken,
      refreshToken,
      tokenType: 'Bearer',
      expiresIn: 3600,
      scope: scopes.join(' '),
    }
  }
}
```

---

## 9. Session Cookie Flow Simulation

New module: `src/infrastructure/session-simulator.ts`

```typescript
/**
 * Session Cookie Flow Simulator
 * Manages session state for cookie-based auth testing.
 */

import { randomBytes } from 'node:crypto'
import { generateTestSessionCookie, parseTestSessionCookie } from './auth-test-helpers.js'
import type { AuthConfig } from '../types.js'

interface Session {
  readonly id: string
  readonly data: Record<string, unknown>
  readonly createdAt: number
}

export class SessionSimulator {
  private readonly sessions: Map<string, Session> = new Map()
  private readonly secret: string

  constructor(config: AuthConfig) {
    this.secret = config.sessionSecret ?? 'test-session-secret-change-in-production'
  }

  createSession(data: Record<string, unknown> = {}): Session {
    const id = randomBytes(16).toString('hex')
    const session: Session = { id, data, createdAt: Date.now() }
    this.sessions.set(id, session)
    return session
  }

  getSession(sessionId: string): Session | undefined {
    return this.sessions.get(sessionId)
  }

  destroySession(sessionId: string): boolean {
    return this.sessions.delete(sessionId)
  }

  generateCookie(sessionId: string): string {
    return generateTestSessionCookie(sessionId, this.secret)
  }

  parseCookie(cookieHeader: string): string | null {
    return parseTestSessionCookie(cookieHeader, this.secret)
  }
}
```

---

## 10. Rate Limiting

### 10.1 Contract Annotations (Annotation Mode)

```typescript
{
  "x-rate-limit": {
    "requests": 100,
    "window": "1m",
    "burst": 10,
    "key": "ip"
  }
}
```

**Annotation semantics**:

- `x-rate-limit.requests`: Maximum requests allowed in the window.
- `x-rate-limit.window`: Time window as a duration string (e.g., `"1m"`, `"1h"`, `"1d"`).
- `x-rate-limit.burst`: Maximum burst size.
- `x-rate-limit.key`: Rate limit bucket key: `"ip"`, `"user"`, `"tenant"`, `"global"`.

### 10.2 Programmatic Rate Limit Config

```typescript
const suite = await fastify.apophis.contract({
  auth: { flow: 'jwt', scopes: ['read:users'] },
  routeRateLimits: {
    'GET /api/data': { requests: 100, window: '1m', burst: 10, key: 'ip' },
    'POST /api/action': { requests: 10, window: '1h', burst: 2, key: 'user' }
  }
})
```

### 10.3 Rate Limit State Tracking

New module: `src/infrastructure/rate-limit-tracker.ts`

```typescript
export interface RateLimitState {
  readonly bucket: string
  readonly remaining: number
  readonly limit: number
  readonly resetAt: number
  readonly window: string
}

export class RateLimitTracker {
  private readonly state: Map<string, RateLimitState> = new Map()

  update(bucket: string, remaining: number, limit: number, resetAt: number, window: string): void {
    this.state.set(bucket, { bucket, remaining, limit, resetAt, window })
  }

  get(bucket: string): RateLimitState | undefined {
    return this.state.get(bucket)
  }

  isExhausted(bucket: string): boolean {
    const state = this.state.get(bucket)
    if (!state) return false
    return state.remaining <= 0 && Date.now() < state.resetAt
  }

  reset(bucket: string): void {
    this.state.delete(bucket)
  }

  getAll(): ReadonlyMap<string, RateLimitState> {
    return this.state
  }
}
```

---

## 11. Scope Registry Integration

The scope registry integrates auth context into scope resolution:

```typescript
// src/infrastructure/scope-registry.ts

getHeaders(
  scopeName: string | null,
  overrides?: Record<string, string>,
  authContext?: AuthContext
): Record<string, string> {
  const scope = scopeName !== null ? this.scopes.get(scopeName) : undefined
  const base = scope ?? this.defaultScope

  const tenantId = base.metadata?.tenantId as string | undefined
  const applicationId = base.metadata?.applicationId as string | undefined

  const headers: Record<string, string> = {
    ...base.headers,
    ...(tenantId !== undefined && tenantId !== 'default' ? { 'x-tenant-id': tenantId } : {}),
    ...(applicationId !== undefined && applicationId !== 'default' ? { 'x-application-id': applicationId } : {}),
    ...(overrides ?? {}),
  }

  // Inject auth headers if auth context is provided
  if (authContext?.token) {
    if (authContext.flow === 'jwt' || authContext.flow === 'oauth2') {
      headers['authorization'] = `Bearer ${authContext.token}`
    } else if (authContext.flow === 'session' && authContext.sessionCookie) {
      headers['cookie'] = authContext.sessionCookie
    }
  }

  // Inject mTLS certificate info if present
  if (authContext?.clientCert && authContext.flow === 'mtls') {
    headers['x-client-cert'] = authContext.clientCert
  }

  return headers
}
```

---

## 12. Request Builder Integration

The request builder injects auth headers based on route requirements and current auth context:

```typescript
// src/domain/request-builder.ts

const buildHeaders = (
  route: RouteContract,
  scopeHeaders: Record<string, string>,
  data: Record<string, unknown>,
  _state: ModelState,
  authContext?: AuthContext
): Record<string, string> => {
  const headers: Record<string, string> = { ...scopeHeaders }

  if (route.schema?.body) {
    headers['content-type'] = 'application/json'
  }

  // Inject auth headers based on route's auth flow requirement
  if (route.authFlow !== 'none' && authContext) {
    if (route.authFlow === 'jwt' || route.authFlow === 'oauth2') {
      if (authContext.token) {
        headers['authorization'] = `Bearer ${authContext.token}`
      }
    } else if (route.authFlow === 'session' && authContext.sessionCookie) {
      headers['cookie'] = authContext.sessionCookie
    } else if (route.authFlow === 'mtls' && authContext.clientCert) {
      headers['x-client-cert'] = authContext.clientCert
    }
  }

  return headers
}
```

---

## 13. Auth Context Initialization in Test Runners

Both `petit-runner.ts` and `stateful-runner.ts` initialize auth context before test execution:

```typescript
// In runPetitTests()

let authContext: AuthContext = {
  flow: config.auth?.flow ?? 'none',
  token: null,
  refreshToken: null,
  tokenExpiry: null,
  sessionCookie: null,
  clientCert: null,
  scopes: [],
  claims: {},
}

if (config.auth && config.auth.flow !== 'none') {
  authContext = await initializeAuth(config.auth)
}

// Pass authContext to buildRequest in the execution loop
for (const command of allCommands) {
  const request = buildRequest(command.route, command.params, scopeHeaders, state, rng, authContext)
  // ...
}
```

**Auth initialization helper**:

```typescript
async function initializeAuth(config: AuthConfig): Promise<AuthContext> {
  switch (config.flow) {
    case 'jwt': {
      const keyPair = config.testKeyPair ?? generateTestKeyPair()
      const token = signTestJwt(
        { sub: 'test-user', scope: (config.scopes ?? []).join(' ') },
        keyPair.privateKey,
        { issuer: config.issuer, audience: config.audience }
      )
      const claims = verifyTestJwt(token, keyPair.publicKey) ?? {}
      return {
        flow: 'jwt',
        token,
        refreshToken: null,
        tokenExpiry: Date.now() + 3600000,
        sessionCookie: null,
        clientCert: null,
        scopes: config.scopes ?? [],
        claims,
      }
    }

    case 'oauth2': {
      const simulator = new OAuthSimulator(config)
      const result = await simulator.clientCredentials({
        clientId: config.clientId ?? 'test-client',
        clientSecret: config.clientSecret ?? `secret-${config.clientId ?? 'test-client'}`,
        scope: (config.scopes ?? []).join(' '),
      })
      const claims = verifyTestJwt(result.accessToken, simulator['keyPair'].publicKey) ?? {}
      return {
        flow: 'oauth2',
        token: result.accessToken,
        refreshToken: result.refreshToken,
        tokenExpiry: Date.now() + result.expiresIn * 1000,
        sessionCookie: null,
        clientCert: null,
        scopes: result.scope.split(' '),
        claims,
      }
    }

    case 'session': {
      const simulator = new SessionSimulator(config)
      const session = simulator.createSession({ userId: 'test-user', roles: config.scopes ?? [] })
      const cookie = simulator.generateCookie(session.id)
      return {
        flow: 'session',
        token: null,
        refreshToken: null,
        tokenExpiry: null,
        sessionCookie: cookie,
        clientCert: null,
        scopes: config.scopes ?? [],
        claims: session.data,
      }
    }

    case 'mtls': {
      return {
        flow: 'mtls',
        token: null,
        refreshToken: null,
        tokenExpiry: null,
        sessionCookie: null,
        clientCert: config.clientCert ?? null,
        scopes: config.scopes ?? [],
        claims: {},
      }
    }

    case 'none':
    default:
      return { flow: 'none', token: null, refreshToken: null, tokenExpiry: null, sessionCookie: null, clientCert: null, scopes: [], claims: {} }
  }
}
```

---

## 14. Contract Extraction

Update `src/domain/contract.ts` to extract auth annotations from schema (annotation mode):

```typescript
const contract: RouteContract = {
  path,
  method: method.toUpperCase(),
  category,
  requires,
  ensures,
  invariants: EMPTY_INVARIANTS,
  regexPatterns: {},
  validateRuntime,
  schema: s,
  // NEW:
  authFlow: (s['x-auth'] as AuthFlow) ?? 'none',
  requiredScopes: Array.isArray(s['x-scopes']) ? (s['x-scopes'] as string[]) : [],
  scopesMatch: (s['x-scopes-match'] as 'any' | 'all') ?? 'any',
  authOptional: s['x-auth-optional'] === true,
  rateLimit: s['x-rate-limit'] ? {
    requests: Number(s['x-rate-limit'].requests) || 100,
    window: String(s['x-rate-limit'].window) || '1m',
    burst: Number(s['x-rate-limit'].burst) || 10,
    key: (s['x-rate-limit'].key as 'ip' | 'user' | 'tenant' | 'global') || 'global',
  } : undefined,
}
```

---

## 15. Example: Arbiter-Style Programmatic Auth

```typescript
import fastify from 'fastify'
import { apophisPlugin } from '@apophis/fastify'

const app = fastify()

// Register APOPHIS with auth support
await app.register(apophisPlugin, {
  scopes: {
    'tenant-a': {
      headers: { 'x-tenant-id': 'tenant-a' },
      metadata: { tenantId: 'tenant-a' }
    }
  }
})

// Arbiter-style route: NO schema annotations for auth
// Auth is handled in preHandler gates (not shown)
app.get('/users/:id', {
  schema: {
    params: { type: 'object', properties: { id: { type: 'string' } } },
    response: {
      200: {
        type: 'object',
        properties: { id: { type: 'string' }, email: { type: 'string' } }
      }
    }
  }
}, async (req, reply) => {
  // Gate-based auth happens in preHandler
  return { id: req.params.id, email: 'user@example.com' }
})

// Test with programmatic auth config
const suite = await app.apophis.contract({
  scope: 'tenant-a',
  auth: {
    flow: 'jwt',
    issuer: 'https://auth.example.com',
    scopes: ['read:users']
  },
  routeAuth: {
    'GET /users/:id': { requiredScopes: ['read:users'] }
  }
})

console.log(`Tests: ${suite.summary.passed} passed, ${suite.summary.failed} failed`)
```

---

## 16. Test Plan

### 16.1 Auth Tests

1. **JWT Flow**: Verify `jwt_claim(this).sub` works with generated test tokens.
2. **OAuth 2.1 Client Credentials**: Verify token acquisition and scope assignment.
3. **OAuth 2.1 Authorization Code + PKCE**: Verify full flow simulation.
4. **Session Cookie**: Verify session creation, cookie generation, and validation.
5. **mTLS**: Verify client certificate injection.
6. **Scope Enforcement**: Verify routes reject requests without required scopes.
7. **Auth Optional**: Verify `x-auth-optional: true` allows unauthenticated access.
8. **Programmatic Mode**: Verify `routeAuth` config works without schema annotations.

### 16.2 Rate Limit Tests

1. **Header Validation**: Verify `response_headers(this).x-ratelimit-remaining >= 0` passes.
2. **Burst Mode**: Verify rapid sequential requests trigger rate limit responses.
3. **State Tracking**: Verify rate limit state persists across requests within one test run and resets between runs.
4. **Contract Violation**: Verify 429 responses are handled correctly when rate limit exceeded.

### 16.3 Integration Tests

1. **Auth + Scope**: Verify JWT route with `read:users` scope works when scope is granted.
2. **Auth + Rate Limit**: Verify authenticated requests are rate-limited per-user.
3. **Scope + Tenant**: Verify tenant isolation with per-tenant auth contexts.
4. **Programmatic + Annotation**: Verify both modes work in the same test run.

---

## 17. Backward Compatibility

All new features are **opt-in**:

- Routes without `x-auth` default to `authFlow: 'none'`.
- Routes without `x-scopes` default to `requiredScopes: []`.
- Routes without `x-rate-limit` default to no rate limit validation.
- Test configurations without `auth` default to no auth context.
- Test configurations without `routeAuth` default to annotation-only mode.

No breaking changes to existing APOPHIS v1.0 APIs.

---

## 18. Security Considerations

1. **Test Keys**: `generateTestKeyPair()` generates 2048-bit RSA keys for testing only. Never use in production.
2. **Session Secrets**: `SessionSimulator` uses a default secret if none provided. Production code must always provide a strong secret.
3. **Token Expiry**: Test JWTs expire after 1 hour by default. Short-lived tokens prevent accidental reuse.
4. **No External Calls**: The OAuth simulator does not make HTTP requests to external IdPs. All tokens are generated locally.
5. **Scope Validation**: Scope checks are exact-match only. No wildcard or regex matching to prevent scope escalation attacks in tests.
6. **mTLS Certificates**: Test client certificates should be generated for each test run. Never reuse production certificates.

---

*End of Revised Specification*